Biomass diversion CO2e case studies
Six public examples of how organizations turn tonnes of food or fish by-product into kg CO2e, from the 100% Great Lakes Fish report to the carbon-market method for food kept in the human food chain.
Six public examples show how organizations turn tonnes of food or fish by-product into kg CO2e. They all use the same logic: tonnes × (emissions on the old route − emissions on the new route), sometimes plus a credit for what the new product replaces. Each card gives who made it, what it calculates, the method, key numbers, watch-outs and links. The step-by-step method is in Calculating kg CO2e from diverted biomass.
100% Great Lakes Fish: fish by-products kept out of landfill
The closest fish-specific example: it puts full use of Great Lakes by-products at roughly 7,000–8,000 t CO2e avoided a year.
- Who
- TriNav Fisheries Consultants for the Conference of Great Lakes St. Lawrence Governors and Premiers (GSGP). GSGP credits the Iceland Ocean Cluster with pioneering the 100% fish idea.
- Calculates
- CO2e and methane avoided when by-products go to products instead of landfill, across four utilization stages.
- Method
- Tonnes landfilled × an EPA figure of about 34 t methane per 907 t of food waste (≈ 838 t CO2e, or ≈ 0.92 t CO2e per tonne), at a methane GWP of 25–28. A scenario table splits 20 million lb of by-product between low-margin uses, high-margin uses and landfill. A second table gives energy (kWh) and emissions per tonne for meal and oil, collagen, pet food, fertilizer, compost and fish leather.
- Key numbers
- Over 9,070 t of by-product a year, of which about 25% (5 million lb) is landfilled today.
- Watch-outs
- The 7,000–8,000 t total treats all ~8,200 t as if it would be landfilled, but the report’s own baseline lands only 25% there. Its executive summary gives 7.9 million lb of CO2 (≈ 3,600 t), about half the figure in the environmental section. Borrow the method, not the totals.
- Links
- Report (PDF) · Initiative overview
US EPA WARM: per-ton factors for each waste route
WARM is the standard US model for comparing waste routes. For food waste, version 16 puts landfilling at +0.50 t CO2e per short ton and composting at −0.15.
- Who
- US Environmental Protection Agency. Version 16 was published in December 2023 as an Excel tool plus an openLCA database.
- Calculates
- The emissions difference between a baseline and an alternative waste plan, per material. Routes: source reduction, recycling, composting, anaerobic digestion, combustion and landfilling. It also reports energy and economic impacts.
- Method
- You enter tonnes by material and route for both scenarios, and WARM returns the difference in t CO2e. Its life-cycle factors are net of credits such as landfill carbon storage and energy recovered from landfill gas.
- Key numbers
- v16, t CO2e per short ton of food waste: landfill 0.50; composting −0.15; anaerobic digestion −0.04 to −0.14, depending on wet or dry digestion and digestate use. Moving food waste from landfill to compost avoids about 0.65 t per short ton (≈ 0.72 t per metric tonne).
- Watch-outs
- Factors reflect US landfill gas capture, grid and soils. Units are short tons (1 short ton = 0.907 t). There is no fish category; “meat only” food waste (landfill 0.46) is the nearest.
ReFED Impact Calculator: surplus food by destination
An online calculator that compares 12 destinations for surplus food, including animal feed. It counts the food production avoided as well as the disposal emissions.
- Who
- ReFED, a US non-profit, using sector-specific emission factors developed by Quantis. It was upgraded in early 2025.
- Calculates
- CO2e (with methane shown separately), water footprint and donated-meal potential, for a current versus an alternative scenario, by sector and food type.
- Method
- Footprint = Σ tons to each destination × (upstream + downstream t CO2e per ton); benefit = current − alternative. Upstream covers production, storage and transport up to retail. Downstream covers landfill methane, energy recovery and landfill carbon storage, or composting transport, energy, fugitive emissions and fertilizer offset. Donation is assumed to avoid half a unit of production per unit donated.
- Key numbers
- 12 destinations and 9 food types, against WARM’s 4 routes. The docs’ retail produce example: landfill downstream 0.33 t CO2e per ton, composting downstream 0.035.
- Watch-outs
- US data and short tons. Built for surplus food in supply chains, not processing by-products such as heads and frames. Prevention and donation results are dominated by avoided production, so don’t compare them directly with a landfill-only factor.
- Links
- Calculator · Methodology · GHG method · 2025 update
CARB / CalRecycle: grant calculators for compost, digestion and food rescue
California’s grant programs publish both the method and an Excel calculator, so every step from tonnes diverted to t CO2e can be inspected.
- Who
- The California Air Resources Board (CARB), for CalRecycle grants funded by California Climate Investments.
- Calculates
- Emission reductions in t CO2e, cost per tonne reduced, and co-benefits such as NOx, PM2.5, fuel savings and compost produced. Two tools matter here: the Organics calculator (composting, anaerobic digestion, co-digestion, community composting) and Food Waste Prevention and Rescue.
- Method
- Net reduction = baseline emissions avoided − new project emissions. Applicants enter tonnes diverted by feedstock (share of food and green waste), compost or digester type, digestate and fuel use, and residues still landfilled. For food rescue: tonnes rescued, extra transport, and refrigeration electricity and refrigerant leaks.
- Factors
- California-specific avoided-landfill factors from CARB’s compost emission reduction work. Food rescue uses the life-cycle emissions of avoidable US food waste, and transport uses CA-GREET.
- Watch-outs
- Only additional material that would otherwise be landfilled counts. Factors are California-specific and versions change by funding year.
Seafish SCEPT: carbon profiles for seafood products
The UK seafood industry’s tool for product carbon footprints. It measures products, not waste routes, so it sits alongside a diversion calculation rather than replacing it.
- Who
- Seafish. Built by Mérieux NutriSciences | Blonk and funded by England’s Fisheries and Seafood Scheme with Seafish. Launched on 3 May 2024 after beta testing from late 2023.
- Calculates
- Carbon footprints of finished seafood products, wild-caught and farmed, and the emission hotspots in each supply chain.
- Method
- Businesses enter their own supply-chain data, such as processing emissions, on a secure platform. A public area shows indicative footprints for typical UK retail products, plus the background methodology and FAQs. Seafish says it supports reporting under the GHG Protocol; the earlier common approach for seafood was PAS 2050-2:2012.
- Uses so far
- Hilton Foods (basa fillets), New England Seafood International (sites and supply chains) and Arctic Traders (road versus sea freight for seabass from Turkey).
- Watch-outs
- The secure section is limited to validated UK seafood businesses, via a request form. It is not built to estimate emissions avoided by diverting by-products from waste.
Verra VM0046: carbon credits for reducing food loss and waste
The carbon-market method for food kept in the human food chain. Its first credits were reported in October 2026, for a US food-rescue project.
- Who
- Verra (Verified Carbon Standard). Version 1.0 was released on 13 July 2023.
- Covers
- Actions that keep food for people across farms, processing, retail, food service and households, such as demand planning, food-sharing apps, donation and dynamic pricing.
- Method
- Net reductions = baseline emissions − project emissions − leakage. The baseline is the destination the food would otherwise reach (landfill, compost or digestion) plus collection and transport, using facility data, a landfill equation or default factors per tonne of dry matter. Project emissions cover transport, processing energy and packaging. Leakage is food that is thrown away later anyway.
- Key numbers
- The first issuance went to Brightly’s US food-rescue project: 721,649 credits (t CO2e) for March 2020–December 2023. Of 15.3 billion lb rescued, 3.1 billion lb qualified after baselines, about 0.5 t CO2e per qualifying tonne (our arithmetic).
- Watch-outs
- Simply switching disposal routes, such as landfill to compost, is excluded. By-products sent to feed or industrial uses would likely not qualify. It still shows the evidence bar for a credible claim: baselines, leakage and third-party verification.
Comparison at a glance
Only the Great Lakes report quantifies fish by-products kept from landfill. The others supply factors or methods to borrow.
| Case study | What it measures | Region | Fish-specific | Access | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 100% Great Lakes Fish | CO2e avoided by using by-products instead of landfill | Great Lakes (US/Canada) | Yes | Public PDF | A template for a 100% Fish impact claim |
| EPA WARM | CO2e per ton for each waste route | US | No (“meat only” nearest) | Free Excel tool | Comparing landfill, compost and digestion |
| ReFED Impact Calculator | CO2e, water and meals by destination | US | No | Online | Surplus food, including animal feed |
| CARB / CalRecycle | Grant-grade reductions and co-benefits | California | No | Free Excel tools and PDFs | Seeing every equation |
| Seafish SCEPT | Product carbon footprints and hotspots | UK | Yes (products) | UK businesses, on request | Footprinting seafood products |
| Verra VM0046 | Verified credits for food kept for people | Global | No | Public methodology | Credit-grade evidence |
Using these for 100% Fish claims
Borrow the Great Lakes structure, but set the baseline from real disposal data for each by-product stream.
- Baseline: route tonnes by stage, as the Great Lakes report does, but count only by-product that would really be landfilled or dumped.
- Factors: take landfill and treatment factors from WARM or the UK government set, or compute them with the IPCC method, and state units and GWP.
- New use: subtract the processing energy and transport of the new product, as in the Great Lakes energy table. Iceland’s low-carbon grid keeps this small.
- Evidence: for anything sold as a credit, follow VM0046’s logic: baseline, leakage and third-party verification.
The full method is in Calculating kg CO2e from diverted biomass.
Estimate yours: the CO2e estimator runs the guide’s steps for the tonnes you keep out of landfill.