100% PLAYBOOK Case Study
← Back to Chapter 1: Assessing your leadership
Case study · Chapter 01

The Scottish Ocean Cluster

Founding Scotland's circular blue economy through careful planning and long-term focus.

  1. 01A two-year development process
  2. 02Learning from international clusters
  3. 03The right people in the room
  4. 04Focused on delivery
  5. 05Circular economy opportunities
  6. 06Lessons and goals
About the Scottish Ocean Cluster
  • Founded by Seafood Scotland, the Industrial Biotechnology Innovation Centre (IBioIC), Zero Waste Scotland, Opportunity North East and Aberdeenshire Council.
  • Launched in March 2025, with origins in pre-Covid discussions around circular economy principles and the challenge of adding value to seafood by-products in a sector defined by tight margins.
  • Progress was gradual through 2023 and early 2024, until a more structured approach was agreed, with a small steering group formed by the Cluster's founders.
  • Current projects span a range of applications, from relatively accessible industrial and agricultural uses of seafood by-products to more advanced biotech opportunities such as enzyme extraction and novel materials.

Scotland's seafood industry is internationally recognized for the quality of its fisheries, aquaculture and processing industries. Yet despite its global reputation, businesses throughout the supply chain continue to face mounting pressures including labor shortages, fluctuating quotas, rising costs, tightening regulations, and the long-term impacts of Brexit and COVID-19.

Rather than viewing these challenges independently, national trade and marketing organization Seafood Scotland recognized an opportunity to create an innovation ecosystem capable of connecting businesses, researchers, technology developers, investors and government around shared opportunities.

Inspired by international examples including the Iceland Ocean Cluster, the Scottish Ocean Cluster was conceived not simply as another industry network but as a long-term vehicle for improving resilience, increasing profitability and creating greater value from Scotland's marine resources.

Donna Fordyce, Chief Executive of Seafood Scotland, explains: “The vision was really to get our seafood industry resilient and profitable. Margins are very small, quotas fluctuate, businesses are struggling to recruit staff, and family companies need confidence that there is a future worth investing in. The Cluster is about helping create that future.”

One of the Scottish Ocean Cluster's early strengths was that it was developed within Seafood Scotland, which was already engaging across the full supply chain – from harvest and processing through to market development, giving it both the credibility and neutrality to convene businesses, researchers, government, and technology partners – organizations that rarely collaborated – directly around a common agenda.

This broad mandate allowed Seafood Scotland to act as an honest broker rather than an advocate for any single interest, creating a trusted environment in which competing businesses, academics and public bodies could collaborate. It also ensures the Cluster's ambitions extend beyond solving individual technical problems to strengthening the resilience and competitiveness of Scotland's entire seafood economy.

As Fordyce puts it: “There was nobody else that was really going to drive this forward. We felt it was our place because we could look at all aspects of the industry and bring those different voices together.”

“The vision was really to get our seafood industry resilient and profitable… The Cluster is about helping create that future.”Donna Fordyce, Seafood Scotland
A deliberate two-year development process

Rather than rushing to establish a new organization, the Scottish Ocean Cluster team deliberately invested almost two years in laying foundations before embarking on any major projects. Fordyce says this measured approach was driven as much by managing expectations as by gathering evidence.

Its Steering Group was acutely aware that businesses were already under significant pressure from labor shortages and rising costs, and many had become weary of consultations that generated little tangible benefit. Therefore, instead of asking industry to bring forward problems before the Cluster had the capacity to respond, the team focused on listening, collecting data, mapping material flows, identifying challenges and communicating regularly on progress. At the same time, it acknowledged the practical limitations of developing a national initiative while everyone involved still had full-time jobs and only modest project funding.

“It was important to understand the landscape properly first,” Fordyce reflects.

Progress came incrementally, but the additional time proved invaluable. It allowed the Steering Group to build credibility, avoid disillusioning stakeholders with unrealistic promises, and to create a robust evidence base that would ultimately strengthen the case for public investment and long-term industry engagement.

Along the way and as the initiative developed, governance of the Cluster evolved significantly. This change reflected the changing needs of the project. In its early stages, the Steering Group had deliberately included a broad range of stakeholders to capture different perspectives and build support. However, having such a wide membership sometimes slowed progress, with too many voices making it difficult to maintain momentum and take decisions. As a result, it was streamlined into a smaller core team capable of meeting regularly, setting clear actions and driving the project forward in a disciplined way, while monthly meetings became highly action-oriented, with clear responsibilities and accountability for delivering agreed tasks.

As the Cluster has gained momentum and secured dedicated staff, its governance has expanded again, but this time from a position of strength. External experts from industry, academia and government have been invited into meetings to challenge assumptions, provide specialist advice and to ensure the Steering Group's thinking remained grounded.

This balance between maintaining a focused leadership team while continuously bringing in fresh perspectives has become one of the defining characteristics of the Scottish Ocean Cluster's collaborative approach, asserts Fordyce.

Learning from international clusters – inside and outside seafood

International collaboration also played a formative role in shaping the Scottish Ocean Cluster, but not simply by providing technical examples of seafood innovation. Throughout the development phase, the Steering Group sought advice from established cluster organizations, learning as much about governance, stakeholder engagement, and long-term strategy as about circular economy opportunities.

Discussions with Norwegian cluster leaders reinforced the importance of first understanding the industry's resource base, material volumes and commercial opportunities before attempting to develop projects, while the Iceland Ocean Cluster demonstrated how a dedicated innovation ecosystem could connect businesses, researchers and entrepreneurs around shared opportunities while creating new value from underutilized marine resources.

As the project evolved, however, the Scottish team deliberately widened its perspective beyond seafood altogether. Attendance at international cluster conferences, including the TCI Global Conference in Dublin, exposed it to successful innovation ecosystems operating across multiple sectors.

These interactions underlined the broader economic impact of cluster models, with evidence from countries such as Denmark and the Great Lakes demonstrating how well-managed clusters stimulate investment, collaboration, business growth and regional competitiveness.

Fordyce advises: “Don't just look at seafood clusters. Look at what other industries and other countries are doing. The principles are transferable, even if every cluster develops differently.”

Indeed, this broader strategic perspective helped reinforce the idea that the Scottish Ocean Cluster should not simply replicate existing models but adapt proven cluster principles to Scotland's own industrial strengths, geography and ambitions.

“It's important to understand that everybody is different – every cluster has its own challenges and opportunities, and there's no ‘plug and play’ model to turn to, but many concepts do already exist so building relations is key,” Fordyce says.

Bringing the right people into the same room

One of the Scottish Ocean Cluster's most significant breakthroughs came when the Steering Group organized regional workshops in Glasgow, Fraserburgh and Oban that brought all parts of the innovation ecosystem together. The result, according to Fordyce, was far richer and more productive than many anticipated. Researchers gained first-hand insight into the operational challenges facing seafood businesses, while processors, fishermen and technology developers discovered expertise and funding opportunities that many had not realized existed.

Rather than acting as a series of consultations, the workshops became catalysts for collaboration, with conversations moving beyond simply identifying problems towards exploring practical solutions.

“We ended up doing it location-wise and having everybody in the room, and that worked so well,” Fordyce says. “The enrichment that we got out of that was incredible.”

Perhaps most revealing was the contrast between the research and commercial communities. Academic institutions often had access to funding and study capability but lacked a clear understanding of industry's priorities, while businesses acknowledged they had little time to pursue innovation because they were focused on keeping day-to-day operations running. The workshops therefore reinforced one of the Cluster's central purposes: to act as the conduit that translates industry challenges into collaborative research and commercial opportunities by connecting the right people at the right time.

As the Scottish Ocean Cluster moved from concept to implementation, the appointment of Dr Tracy White as Project Manager in late 2025 provided expertise in science, biotechnology and innovation, as well as an understanding of how research organizations and funding mechanisms operate.

It was also recognized the cluster needed someone with deep commercial credibility within the seafood industry itself. The subsequent recruitment of Engagement Manager Steve Marr, whose career spans seafood processing and wider food manufacturing, added a complementary set of skills and relationships. Together, the pair embody the Cluster's core mission of connecting industry with innovation.

“It was clear we needed two different strands,” Fordyce says. “This is what we're trying to bring together – people from very different backgrounds who need to work together to develop solutions.”

She adds that the appointees' combined expertise has strengthened the cluster's ability to identify opportunities, translate challenges into projects and build confidence among both commercial and research partners.

Focused on delivery, not ‘talking shop’

Throughout the Scottish Cluster's development, Fordyce has remained adamant that it cannot simply become another forum for discussion. While networking, consultation and relationship building were essential during the early stages, she knew that businesses would ultimately judge it on its ability to deliver tangible outcomes.

“We couldn't be a talking shop,” she says. “There are plenty of other forums where people can go and talk about things. We have to have deliverables. We have to demonstrate to companies that we can help them add more value to their waste streams.”

This philosophy shaped the Cluster's culture from the outset: Steering Group meetings are designed to be action-focused, with clear responsibilities and follow-up actions, while workshops and events are structured around identifying opportunities for collaboration rather than simply discussing challenges.

As the Cluster has matured, the emphasis has increasingly shifted toward project development, funding opportunities and creating measurable value from seafood side-streams. The rapid evolution of what was originally intended to be a small networking event into the Scottish Ocean Cluster's inaugural summit also reflects this mindset; participants are not just looking for conversation but for pathways to innovation, partnerships and investment.

The summit's program also evolved to include interactive pitching sessions, opportunities for companies to present challenges and technologies, and dedicated networking designed to stimulate new collaborations. High-profile speakers and facilitators, including representatives from major seafood businesses and international cluster partners, further reinforced the sector's enthusiasm and appetite for circular economy innovation.

For Fordyce, maintaining that focus on delivery is critical to the Cluster's long-term credibility. Its success will ultimately be measured not by the number of meetings held, but by the projects launched, collaborations created, and economic value generated for Scotland's seafood sector, she says.

Unique circular economy opportunities

While the Scottish Ocean Cluster has drawn significant inspiration from the Iceland Ocean Cluster's internationally recognized “100% Fish” philosophy, Scotland's circular economy opportunities are shaped by a different resource base and industrial landscape. Therefore, rather than simply replicating the Icelandic model, the Cluster has focused on identifying where the greatest untapped value exists within Scotland's own seafood sector.

Much of the country's fish is already utilized, with processing by-products entering established markets such as fishmeal and fish oil. The opportunity, therefore, lies in extracting greater value before those materials enter lower-value pathways, or in finding productive uses for side-streams that currently represent a disposal cost. Shell waste has emerged as one of the most immediate priorities, particularly the large volumes of scallop shells generated by processors, alongside growing interest in fish skins for applications ranging from biomaterials to collagen-based products.

The Cluster is also exploring opportunities around currently unutilized side-streams, including fish viscera that are routinely discarded at sea but may contain commercially valuable compounds if landed and processed. At the same time, enquiries are increasingly arriving from biotechnology companies seeking reliable access to these materials, reinforcing the view that innovation is being driven not only by industry looking to reduce waste but also by emerging markets searching for new sustainable raw materials.

For Fordyce, the ambition is not to compete with existing fishmeal markets, but to identify where additional value can be created while reducing disposal costs and opening entirely new commercial opportunities for processors.

Critical lessons and far-reaching goals

Reflecting on the Cluster's development, Fordyce says one of the biggest lessons along the way was recognizing that building an innovation ecosystem requires patience, sustained investment and a willingness to evolve assumptions along the way.

Early ambitions for the Scottish Ocean Cluster to become financially self-sufficient within a few years gave way to a more realistic understanding that successful clusters internationally operate through long-term collaborations between industry, academia and government, with each contributing resources and sharing ownership.

Also, government support, she argues, should not be viewed simply as seed funding but as an ongoing partnership that helps de-risk innovation and unlock wider economic benefits.

The Cluster also learned the importance of measuring impact from the outset. Significant effort has therefore gone into establishing baseline data on Scotland's seafood side-streams, despite the challenges of working with fragmented U.K. trade statistics and an industry where much of the catch is exported for processing elsewhere. The long-term objective is to develop systems capable of tracking not only material volumes but also the increasing value generated through innovation projects.

Equally important has been maintaining strategic focus. Although opportunities continue to emerge across areas such as marine litter, ghost gear and wider blue economy initiatives, the Cluster has deliberately resisted expanding its remit too quickly.

Fordyce believes that clearly defining priorities, regularly challenging assumptions through external advisors and remaining disciplined about what the organization can realistically deliver have been essential in transforming the Cluster from an ambitious idea into a credible delivery organization capable of generating measurable economic impact.

Patience has also been critical.

“It took longer to get here than we initially thought,” she says. “It also takes time to engage industry, and then they need to appreciate it takes time to get these initiatives up and running. But our hope is more and more companies will see that in these tough times they can maintain, if not grow, their turnover, and this will allow them to invest in new technologies, which are desperately needed.”

Ultimately, the aim is for the Scottish Ocean Cluster to become more than an innovation program. Its overriding ambition, Fordyce reiterates, is to strengthen Scotland's coastal economy by helping seafood businesses become more profitable, encouraging new biotechnology companies to establish themselves in Scotland, supporting higher-value employment, and creating stronger connections between industry, science and investment.

“If we can help businesses generate more value from what they already have, then we're strengthening the long-term future of Scotland's seafood industry.”Donna Fordyce, Seafood Scotland

“We want to see more companies investing, creating higher-value jobs, thriving coastal communities and a flourishing blue biotechnology sector. If we can help businesses generate more value from what they already have, then we're strengthening the long-term future of Scotland's seafood industry and in turn contributing to a stronger economy.”

With Donna Fordyce, Chief Executive, Seafood Scotland · scottishoceancluster.com

← Back to Chapter 1: Assessing your leadership