100% PLAYBOOK Case Study
← Back to Chapter 5: Convening your ecosystem
Case study · Chapter 05

The Namibia Ocean Cluster

Turning seafood residuals into a collective, valuable resource.

  1. 01Making waste visible
  2. 02A collective opportunity
  3. 03Unicorns aren't made overnight
  4. 04The importance of patience
  5. 05From utilization to optimization
About the Namibia Ocean Cluster
  • Launched in April 2024 as a legally-registered non-profit entity, with the founding and associate members signing a commitment to minimise waste and maximise the socio-economic value of fish harvested from the Namibian fisheries sector. This mission aligns with UN FAO's SDG 12.3 of halving food loss and waste by 2030.
  • As Africa's first Ocean Cluster, it operates as a pre-competitive forum for collaboration across the seafood value chain. Cluster Chair Pierre Le Roux (Sales & Marketing Manager at Seawork) leads the organization, which is backed by the World Economic Forum's Ocean Action Agenda and UK's Blue Planet Fund.
  • The founders represent a wider group who have supported the development and innovation activities of the Ocean Cluster over the last three years.
  • The overriding goal is to promote innovation, research and markets for fisheries by-products while enhancing socio-economic benefit with the aim to catalyse increasing efforts, both nationally and regionally, to develop circular models across the seafood industry.
Six founding members: MSC-certified hake fishing companies
  • Embwinda
  • Hangana
  • Merlus
  • Novanam
  • Pereira
  • Seawork
Five non-fishing associate members
  • Fisheries Observers Agency
  • Namibia Nature Foundation
  • Sam Nujoma Campus, University of Namibia
  • The coastal campus of the International University of Management, with its newly established modern lab facilities
  • Fishmeal processor and hake liver oil pilot producer Seanam Fishing

Namibia's hake fishery was not chosen as a testbed for seafood utilization because it was doing something wrong. Quite the opposite: The fishery was well established, economically important and Marine Stewardship Council (MSC) certified. At the same time, the Namibian government recognized the contribution fisheries make to nutrition, livelihoods and employment, while the country had also committed to developing a more sustainable ocean economy through its President's membership of the High Level Panel for a Sustainable Ocean Economy. Yet, like many whitefish fisheries around the world, much of the hake was being headed and gutted at sea, with the heads and viscera returned to the ocean.

There were perfectly rational reasons for doing so. The fish not only took up less space once headed and gutted, but also quality was maintained longer. There was also no established viable market for the material, while keeping it onboard would consume valuable storage capacity and require additional handling.

But when a World Economic Forum (WEF) project began exploring options with the fishing companies, the decision was taken to better understand just how much nutrition and quantity of material was being left at sea. The objective of the project, funded through the U.K. government's Defra Blue Fund, which officially began in 2020 and ran through 2024, was to explore whether replicable models for zero-waste and full valorization of seafood in commercial seafood production could be developed.

In this regard, Namibia offered some favorable enabling conditions. Among these, all of the industrial fishing and processing businesses were geographically concentrated in just two towns along the coast, and many were vertically integrated.

Arguably the biggest challenge was that there was little obvious incentive for the companies to change how they had operated for decades.

“The companies have strong markets, MSC certification and had little incentive to change the way they operate,” recalls Melanie Siggs, who worked with WEF on the project. “It was a good example of you don't want to change a system if it's not broken. So we had to demonstrate how change could add more value on a number of levels.”

That meant the project could not simply arrive with a prescription for “100% Fish” and expect the industry to embrace it, she says. Instead, the first year was spent talking, listening, exploring. And talking separately, with the fishing companies convened separately from the NGOs, academics and policymakers so everyone felt confident to talk openly.

It was only around halfway through the second year that the different groups were ready to be brought together, thus pooling their knowledge and expertise.

Making waste visible

The first breakthrough came through the relatively simple exercise of putting numbers on what was being left at sea. The project calculated the tonnage of hake heads and viscera being discarded and began assessing their nutritional value.

“I genuinely believe it was the first fishery to have ever done that,” Siggs says.

Crucially, the data changed the conversation. “Suddenly we had numbers which made this material real. It wasn't just something that happened on fishing trips without thought. People started to notice.”

The point was not simply to produce another report about seafood waste. Quantification created the basis for a commercial conversation. Once the material could be measured, it could begin to be treated as a resource. This became part of the replicable models WEF created for all fisheries to adopt – first measure the available material being lost that could be a resource.

It transpired that around 50,000 tons of hake heads and nearly 3,500 tons of hake livers were being left at sea annually.

Hake livers emerged as an obvious opportunity. Hake liver is comparable to cod liver, and the global market for fish oils is substantial. Every 4 kilograms of discarded hake livers can yield around 750 milliliters of omega-3-rich hake liver oil. The team also examined what was being discarded in processing plants, finding opportunities around frames, small pieces of residual meat and skin.

Samples of skin were sent to Iceland for analysis of its collagen and gelatin content. Again, the results suggested a potentially valuable resource, particularly given the scale and growth of global collagen markets.

This was the point at which attitudes began to shift.

“Once it's actually a valuable material and resource rather than a waste product, it takes on a completely different mindset,” Siggs says.

“Once it's actually a valuable material and resource rather than a waste product, it takes on a completely different mindset.”Melanie Siggs, World Economic Forum project

The distinction is important. The project was not telling companies that they had suddenly discovered waste. They had always known the material was there. What changed was the perception of what that material represented.

From individual waste to collective opportunity

The next obstacle was scale. Several companies had looked at opportunities for their own residual material prior to the project, but had concluded that there simply wasn't enough to make it economically viable.

That's where the cluster model became important. If one company did not have enough hake liver, skin or other material to create a viable feedstock, perhaps several companies could combine their resources if they could safely find a way to work together.

But this introduced another challenge: the companies were competitors. The project therefore had to create a space where they could cooperate without compromising their competitive positions.

“The competitive edge is competing on the hake markets where they each have their strong individual position,” Siggs explains, “but when it comes to the hake livers or skins it made sense to pool resources and see what they could achieve together.”

That distinction between competition and pre-competitive collaboration became central to the Namibia model.

Eventually, six fishing companies, controlling around 70% of the total allowable catch of hake in Namibia's waters, committed to moving forward. A charter was developed to establish the Namibia Ocean Cluster's rules of engagement, with the fishing company members retaining voting rights while universities, NGOs, and other supporting organizations could participate without controlling decisions about the material. This allows fishing industry members to draw on the expertise of these associate members, but ensure they retain all business decisions.

As well as signing up to the charter of rules (i.e. the governance of the Cluster), the companies agreed to contribute financially towards the Cluster and to appoint a third-party secretariat.

Getting to that point, however, required considerably more work than simply putting the companies in a room. The project team spent six months working with the company representatives to help prepare their CEOs for participation in the Cluster.

Siggs explained that it was very important that the CEOs knew about the work, and felt committed and comfortable with the Cluster, its objectives and the charter.

The CEOs were carefully prepared for a meeting in which they would understand exactly what was being proposed and what they would be asked to commit. Interestingly one company stepped down during that process which was important in itself. Better at that stage and they could join later.

“For me, that CEO C-suite buy-in was critical to success,” Siggs commented.

The preparation paid off in an unexpected way. When the CEOs came together and after the formalities Siggs went around the room asking each CEO whether they were prepared to sign the charter and commit financially for three years. The preparation meant it was unlikely any would say ‘no’, but the surprise was that several offered more than had been asked for.

Unicorns aren't made overnight

There was another challenge for the Namibia Ocean Cluster to overcome: expectations.

The success of the Iceland Ocean Cluster, and companies such as medical technologists Kerecis, offered a mouthwatering vision of what seafood by-products could achieve. But it also risked creating unrealistic expectations: A fishing company looking at the value of hake liver in the nutraceutical market could easily jump to the conclusion that they should process the material, create a finished product, establish a brand, and sell it directly into global markets.

Siggs's advice was considerably more pragmatic given the level of investment both in technology, licensing, expertise, and market development needed.

They were reminded that developing a high-value finished product requires infrastructure, investment, specialist expertise and, crucially, a market. Therefore, for Namibia, a more realistic first step might be to sell the livers as a raw material or process them into an oil that could then be sold to an established downstream business.

That's a subtle but important distinction for other fisheries considering utilization, she says. The objective isn't necessarily to turn a fishing company into a nutraceutical manufacturer, cosmetics company or pharmaceutical business. It may simply be to create a reliable, consistent and sufficiently valuable feedstock for someone else to use.

“End markets and understanding their requirements is critical,” Siggs says.

Before investing in processing equipment, a fishery needs to understand who will buy the resulting material, what specification they require, what quality and purity standards apply, how much material they need and what price they are prepared to pay. In other words, she says, the end markets should help determine the processing pathway rather than being an afterthought.

This is one of the key distinctions between the Namibian experience and the better-known Icelandic model. The Iceland Ocean Cluster, Siggs notes, effectively created a space where entrepreneurs could access underused residual seafood materials and develop businesses from them.

Namibia is taking a different route whereby the fishing industry itself was encouraged to recognize the value of its residual material and collectively develop mechanisms to retain and valorize it.

What's important, she adds, is to recognize there's no single 100% Fish model, it will vary on the conditions of the region and the fisheries.

A cluster might be for-profit or not-for-profit. It might be entrepreneur-led or industry-led. It might be built around a particular geographical concentration of fishing businesses, or around a shared processing facility, a university or another anchor organization.

“You have to be very open-minded as to what the actual cluster model looks like to find that which will work for the objective and the industry opportunities,” Siggs says.

The importance of patience

If there is one characteristic that the Namibia experience makes particularly clear, it's that ecosystem development takes time.

The project officially began in 2020, but the process of building relationships, developing the cluster structure, and securing commitment from companies took a third-party four years to create such that it was embedded in the sector locally. The time was invested in carefully building trust and knowledge and proposing models rather than attempting to quickly change systems in place.

That can be difficult when projects are expected to demonstrate quick commercial results.

Instead of having a very fixed vision of how the process will evolve, Siggs encourages that the objective should be to establish a direction of travel and allow the pathway to evolve. And for a project dealing with unfamiliar markets, technologies and business models, that flexibility can be a strength rather than a weakness. Having a third-party (the WEF) steering and guiding that process was enormously helpful given the businesses don't typically have that level of spare resource to make things happen or the neutrality to lead collaboration.

The Namibia Ocean Cluster confirms that a lot of important lessons have already been learned, and that with time and more strategic research, there's absolutely an opportunity to develop a significant new sector within Namibia that's focused on producing new, high-value products from previously discarded fisheries resources.

“Nobody likes to waste their fish quota, by discarding offcuts overboard,” Pierre Le Roux, Director and Chair of the Namibia Ocean Cluster, states. “However, it was only with the foundational research undertaken while initiating development of the Cluster that the realization struck that valuable byproducts could be produced from this waste, suddenly opening the door to the strategic realization that 100% Fish for Profit is possible. Now we are undertaking careful research, step-by-step, directed at turning this into commercial reality.”

The Cluster's aim, therefore, is to promote new models, new research methods, and establish markets to maximize this full fish utilization. The Cluster also recognizes that while it's currently focused on wild-capture fisheries, in the longer-term this could be extended to other blue economy sectors, including aquaculture.

“We hope to expand membership to non-fishing sectors like aquaculture and connect with regional stakeholders, operating in the same fisheries,” says Le Roux. “We are also in the process of moving from data collection to developing specific market products, and meeting new players in this space of innovation as momentum builds. This is bearing fruit by bringing new contacts with real expertise and creative thinking, significantly accelerating progress and creating an exciting, dynamic new environment to work in. We are looking forward to seeing what the future holds.”

From full utilization to optimization

Meanwhile, the Namibia project also led Siggs to question the terminology surrounding the 100% Fish concept itself.

“Full utilization” sounds straightforward, but it can mean very different things in different economies, she says. In a low-income country, for example, a seafood might more typically be fully utilized. The problem may instead be that poor handling or a lack of refrigeration causes valuable nutrition to be lost before the fish reaches consumers – a very different kind of loss requiring very different solutions. However, the cluster model where, for example, people work together to build cooperative cold stores that are co-managed are not unusual.

In a highly industrialized seafood economy, the challenge may be different: a fishery can be sustainably managed and certified, yet significant parts of the animal may still be discarded at sea or during processing while the highest value part of the fish provides sufficient profit to support operations.

Siggs increasingly prefers the word “optimization” because it encompasses both situations. The objective, she says, is not simply to find a commercial use for every part of a fish, it's to optimize its nutritional and economic value and minimize avoidable losses.

For Namibia, the longer-term opportunity is much bigger than simply finding additional food products. Collagen, chitin, chitosan, oils, calcium and other compounds derived from seafood could increasingly feed into nutraceutical, pharmaceutical, medical and industrial markets, and a future in which fishing businesses are supplying such high-value industries could look very different.

There's also the potential to create quality fishmeal or hydrolysate from residual material and fish heads which could either support the emerging aquaculture industry in Namibia as well as overseas aquaculture and petfood companies. At the same time, it's recognized that around 50 to 54% of the world's total fish oil production now comes from processing by-products and trimmings rather than whole wild-caught fish.

“There are many opportunities to maximize usage across Namibia's fisheries value chain, from high-value extraction for pharmaceuticals, nutraceuticals, and cosmetics, such as collagen and supplements such as fish oil, to producing products that could form the basis for micronutrients that supplement baby food. The idea is to find products that for example, make it worthwhile to bring ashore the fish heads, utilizing what we can for higher value products, including those for human consumption, and using the remainder for fishmeal or oil ingredients that are in high demand for aqua and animal feeds,” says Le Roux.

“Thanks to the Cluster's activities, we've seen greater trust and open communication between industry, regulators and NGOs, as well as networking on research with scientific institutions like universities,” Le Roux continues. “People's mindsets are shifting away from ‘waste.’ Reducing losses and promoting the circular blue economy is about innovation and networking. We were initially funded by donors and see the Cluster development as an exciting area for continued donor involvement through university research, creating a biotechnology framework in Namibia with the support of Government, that opens up product development, creating new job opportunities, and broadening the country's skills base.”

“People's mindsets are shifting away from ‘waste.’ Reducing losses and promoting the circular blue economy is about innovation and networking.”Pierre Le Roux, Namibia Ocean Cluster

The Namibia project is not yet that future. But what it does provide is a practical demonstration of how to start moving towards it: measure what is being discarded; establish its nutritional and economic value; understand the market; bring competitors together around a pre-competitive opportunity; and build the governance and commercial structures needed to act.

Most importantly, it shows that the first step towards 100% Fish does not necessarily involve a revolutionary new technology. Sometimes it begins with a more fundamental change in perspective and the recognition that the material nobody thought was worth landing may end up being the most interesting resource in the fishery.

With Melanie Siggs, World Economic Forum project, and Pierre Le Roux, Chair, Namibia Ocean Cluster · namibiaoceancluster.org

← Back to Chapter 5: Convening your ecosystem