The Great Lakes 100% Fish Initiative
Building the world's first fully-integrated freshwater 100% Fish ecosystem.
The Great Lakes, by the numbers
- The Great Lakes commercial fishery is valued at approximately CAD 420 million and supports nearly 3,000 jobs.
- Traditionally, only 40% of the 35 million pounds of fish commercially landed (the fillet) is sold into the market.
- The region produces over 20 million pounds of fisheries by-products annually, at an estimated disposal cost of approximately CAD 2.7 million.
- About 75% of total fish by-products are utilised today, mostly into low-margin value chains. GSGP estimates full utilisation and diversification into high-margin chains could unlock over CAD 50 million per year.
- Redirecting fish waste from landfills reduces methane emissions; using bycatch and invasive species for fishmeal or bait reduces pressure on at-risk forage fish like herring and mackerel.
- Beyond new jobs, utilising fish by-products could extend the operational season for processors and benefit their bottom line.
Stretching across eight US states and two Canadian provinces, the Great Lakes region supports one of the world's most significant freshwater ecosystems and a vast, highly diverse seafood economy that spans commercial fisheries, aquaculture, recreational fishing, seafood processing, tribal fisheries, logistics and food production. But like many seafood regions globally, it also faces mounting pressures: declining stocks in some fisheries, fragmented supply chains, rising disposal costs, an ageing fishing community, landfill constraints and growing demand for more sustainable and efficient resource use.
For the Conference of Great Lakes St Lawrence Governors & Premiers (GSGP), these challenges created an opportunity to rethink how fish resources are valued and utilised across the region. Inspired by the global 100% Fish movement pioneered by the Iceland Ocean Cluster, GSGP launched the 100% Great Lakes Fish Initiative to explore how full-utilisation principles could be adapted within a complex freshwater ecosystem.
This hasn't been a theoretical sustainability exercise, explains John Schmidt, Programme Manager at GSGP. Instead, it's a practical strategy for economic resilience, waste reduction, regional innovation and long-term fisheries viability.
Rather than focusing on maximising fillet yields, the initiative set out to identify commercially viable uses for underutilised biomass streams, including skins, frames, viscera and scales, while simultaneously creating new economic opportunities for fishing communities, processors, entrepreneurs and indigenous groups across the region. The result has become one of the most ambitious attempts anywhere to build a fully-integrated freshwater 100% Fish ecosystem spanning commercial and recreational fisheries, aquaculture and processing.
“We don't have one dominant species, one national fishery, or a single, centralised fishing and processing cluster. We have this very distributed binational region with commercial fisheries, aquaculture, recreational fishing, tribal groups, processors, researchers, entrepreneurs, all sorts of folks. So our work has really been about adapting the 100% Fish idea into something practical for our region.”John Schmidt, GSGP
The starting point: fragmented systems and underutilised resources
The initiative began with a recognition that substantial volumes of fish biomass across the Great Lakes region remained underutilised or disposed of through landfill and waste streams. Commercial processing by-products, recreational fish-cleaning waste, aquaculture side-streams and materials like skins, frames, viscera and scales were often treated as disposal costs rather than economic assets.
At the same time, some of the region's commercially important species, particularly Lake Whitefish, were facing mounting pressures linked to stock declines, changing economics and shifting consumer behaviour. "We heard from fish processors who were concerned about the long-term future of their businesses, including whether the next generation would want to continue, and how to remain viable amid long hours, tight margins and growing operational complexity," Schmidt recalls.
The fragmented nature of the industry created additional complexity. Unlike vertically-integrated seafood systems, the Great Lakes supply chain consists of many independent actors (fishermen, processors, distributors, middlemen, aquaculture operators and recreational fisheries) often operating very separately from one another.
The intervention: adapting the 100% Fish model to freshwater systems
The turning point came when GSGP made Lake Whitefish its focus and began building a regionally adapted freshwater interpretation of the 100% Fish concept. The organisation started with extensive scientific, operational and market analysis to understand the full system before attempting implementation. "We realised very quickly that we needed to understand the whole ecosystem before making practical recommendations," Schmidt says.
The initiative developed a multi-stage strategy built around:
- Biomass and byproduct mapping
- Biotechnical testing of regional species
- Market analysis and product feasibility studies
- Stakeholder engagement and coalition building
- Prototype product development
- Commercial pathway identification
- Public communication and awareness building
A major early exercise involved establishing the accessible volumes, seasonality, geographic concentration, species availability and handling practices across the region. "We needed to know not just that the material existed, but where it was, how consistent it was, how it was handled, and whether anybody was willing to separate, freeze, store or transport it differently," Schmidt says.
This work revealed clear geographic clusters where commercial opportunities could potentially scale, despite the broader fragmentation of the fishery. Detailed biotechnical testing on regional species then identified the highest-value opportunities for side streams and underutilised biomass, uncovering applications including fishmeal and fish oil, pet treats, composts and fertilisers, fish leather, protein hydrolysates, collagen products, bait applications and specialty biological materials. Some opportunities proved surprisingly accessible. "One guy is even making fish leather in his backyard," Schmidt notes. "That showed us there's really no minimum scale. There are opportunities at every level."
Building the ecosystem: the 100% Great Lakes Fish Pledge
One of the initiative's most influential innovations was the creation of the 100% Great Lakes Fish Pledge. Designed as both a public commitment and a practical collaboration mechanism, the pledge brought together processors, fishers, aquaculture operators, recreational fishing stakeholders, researchers and manufacturers under a shared commitment to full utilisation principles. "We wanted something that functioned almost like a cluster organisation," Schmidt says.
The overriding goal of the pledge is to achieve 100% utilisation of each fish caught, raised or processed in the region, with the idea itself emerging during discussions in an Icelandic hot spring, following meetings with the Iceland Ocean Cluster. Today it includes nearly 50 signatories, representing approximately 90% of the commercial catch within the region. Signatories have made the following core commitments:
- Using all parts of each fish productively, eliminating waste.
- Implementing strategies to maximise the value derived from all parts of the fish where and when practical.
- Exploring investment in new technologies and processes that allow for the efficient extraction and production of protein, collagen, leather and other valuable by-products of the traditional production process.
- Sharing the pledge and its message with partners throughout the value chain and encouraging them to make similar commitments toward fostering the sustainability of the region's fisheries.
- Remaining open to expanding the idea of 100% Fish to other Great Lakes fish and exploring the sustainable commercial harvesting and utilisation of new species that may present opportunities for complementary businesses.
The pledge has also created a number of crucial outcomes, including a trusted stakeholder network, a practical communication channel, a mechanism for project coordination, a framework for shared identity and momentum, and a platform for attracting new collaborators and investors. "It became one of the most impactful things we've done to date," Schmidt says.
Purposeful outcomes: operational, commercial and environmental gains
Although still evolving, the initiative has already generated significant strategic outcomes. From a commercial and economic perspective, the programme's research estimates suggest that existing underutilised biomass streams across the Great Lakes region could generate approximately CAD 30 million annually in additional economic value through currently identifiable applications alone, including high-volume fishmeal and oil production, premium fish-skin pet treats, compost and agricultural fertiliser, fish leather products, and protein extraction and hydrolysates.
Importantly, the initiative deliberately focused not only on large-scale industrial opportunities but also on smaller, decentralised business models suited to rural communities and small operators. "We wanted to identify opportunities that small and medium-sized operators could realistically participate in," Schmidt explains.
On the environmental side, the initiative has also positioned itself as a major circular economy and sustainability programme within the region. By diverting fish biomass from landfill and wastewater systems, the project has contributed to reduced methane and landfill emissions, reduced nutrient runoff, improved resource efficiency, circular bioeconomy development, waste minimisation and lower disposal costs. The programme estimates that full implementation could significantly reduce greenhouse gas emissions associated with disposal while supporting broader regional environmental goals. In Ontario specifically, where landfill capacity is becoming increasingly constrained, the initiative aligns directly with provincial waste-diversion priorities.
“It's not just about using more of the fish. It's about becoming more intentional with how we use these resources overall.”John Schmidt, GSGP
Keeping focus: overcoming decisive barriers and expediting enablers
One of the defining characteristics of the 100% Great Lakes Fish Initiative has been its ability to translate an ambitious circular economy concept into something practical, regionally relevant and capable of gaining traction across a highly fragmented freshwater seafood system. But the journey from concept to implementation has required persistence, adaptation and plenty of coalition building.
At the centre of the initiative's momentum has been the leadership inside GSGP, with Schmidt and the organisation's Executive Director David Naftzger championing the idea internally while steadily building external credibility across the region. Rather than attempting to impose a ready-made model, GSGP invested heavily in understanding the realities of the Great Lakes fisheries and tailoring the 100% Fish concept accordingly, spending years travelling across the region, meeting processors, fishers, tribal organisations, aquaculture operators, researchers and entrepreneurs face-to-face. "We had to spend a lot of time putting in the miles," Schmidt explains. "You have to show up, build trust and be prepared to explain the idea over and over again."
That trust-building process proved especially important given the structure and culture of the Great Lakes coastal economy, with its many small-scale operators and family-run businesses with long histories. "There was a lot of initial scepticism," Schmidt recalls. "People would ask: who are you, why are you here, and what do you want to do with our fish?" Overcoming these perceptions required patience and practical engagement rather than top-down policy messaging. Early success came from identifying respected industry participants willing to engage with the concept first. Once a core group of businesses became involved, wider participation followed more naturally through industry relationships and peer-to-peer trust.
International collaboration also played a critical enabling role. Early engagement with the Iceland Ocean Cluster helped provide both inspiration and proof that a full-utilisation seafood economy could be commercially viable at scale, but just as important was the freedom to adapt the concept independently rather than replicate Iceland's model directly. "The Icelanders sparked a vision," Schmidt says. "But this is not a plug-and-play solution." One of the earliest operational barriers emerged around biotechnical testing and product analysis: initially, fish samples were shipped to Iceland for testing, but logistical delays, customs issues and transportation costs quickly exposed the limitations of relying on overseas infrastructure. This eventually pushed GSGP towards building more localised North American research partnerships and testing capacity, a shift that has not only improved efficiency but also strengthened regional ownership of the initiative itself.
Long-term sustainability is an important consideration for any circular economy or cluster-building initiative. Schmidt says one of the key lessons has been to think early about how a programme can be supported by a mix of partners, funding sources and practical value for participants. "From the outset, it helps to build a broad base of support and make sure the work is creating enough value that partners remain engaged over time," he says. "That gives the initiative a stronger foundation for long-term growth."
At the same time, the initiative has benefited enormously from strategic storytelling and public visibility. GSGP deliberately treated communications and media engagement as a core part of the programme rather than an afterthought, a visibility that has helped generate industry interest, attract collaborators, strengthen funding applications, and position the Great Lakes initiative within the wider global 100% Fish movement. According to GSGP, it has generated more than 350 media stories, approximately USD 31 million in earned media value, and an estimated audience reach of 100 million people.
“This is a compelling story. People respond to the combination of innovation, sustainability and tangible economic opportunity.”John Schmidt, GSGP
That public profile has continued to grow through international recognition, including the Seafood Industry Climate Award and the UN Food and Agriculture Organization's Blue Transformation Leaders Award, accolades that have helped validate the initiative while reinforcing confidence among stakeholders.
Taking the 100% Fish journey: practical lessons and replicability
Looking ahead, GSGP's long-term ambition remains highly ambitious: creating the world's first 100% freshwater fisheries, spanning commercial fisheries, aquaculture and recreational fishing. Current priorities include expanding the 100% Sport Fish programme, increasing side-stream utilisation infrastructure, supporting new entrepreneurs and innovators, advancing higher-value product development, building additional regional processing partnerships, and exploring future cluster organisation models.
GSGP asserts that progress has depended less on any single technology or product opportunity and more on its ability to connect environmental goals, economic realities and regional identity into a shared long-term vision. What began as a relatively small exploration of fish by-product utilisation has evolved into a broader cluster-building exercise, one that continues to expand its participant reach and engagement. It also offers several important considerations for other regions seeking to implement 100% Fish or broader circular seafood systems:
- Adapt the model to local realities. The Great Lakes initiative demonstrates that successful replication requires adapting principles, not copying structures.
- Invest heavily in foundational research. Understanding biomass availability, species characteristics, logistics, handling practices and market opportunities proved essential before implementation.
- Build relationships before infrastructure. Stakeholder trust and coalition building have been prerequisites for operational progress.
- Think across the entire ecosystem. Integrating commercial fisheries, aquaculture and recreational fishing significantly expanded both scale and opportunity.
- Create visible public momentum. Media visibility, storytelling, awards and public engagement helped generate legitimacy, attract partners and maintain political support.
- Balance high-volume and high-value opportunities. Large-scale uses such as fishmeal and oil may provide the economic engine that enables higher-value niche applications to emerge later.
- Stay flexible. Political priorities, funding conditions, species availability and market opportunities evolve constantly. "You can't be rigid," Schmidt says. "You've got to stay creative and keep moving."
Ultimately, the Great Lakes initiative demonstrates that while the pathways are often complex, circular seafood principles can evolve beyond marine fisheries into broader freshwater bioeconomy systems. Perhaps most importantly, it shows that 100% Fish is not simply a waste-reduction concept, but a framework for regional economic resilience, ecosystem stewardship, innovation and long-term community sustainability.
With John Schmidt, Programme Manager, Conference of Great Lakes St Lawrence Governors & Premiers · 100% Great Lakes Fish